Introduction

Welding creates complex microstructural zones that require specialized preparation techniques for accurate metallographic analysis. A typical weld contains multiple distinct regions: the weld metal (fusion zone), the heat-affected zone (HAZ), the fusion boundary, and the unaffected base metal. Each region has different microstructures and properties that must be properly revealed through careful sample preparation.

Proper preparation of weld samples is essential for:

Evaluating weld quality and integrity
Detecting defects (cracks, porosity, inclusions)
Analyzing microstructural changes in the HAZ
Verifying weld penetration and fusion
Assessing post-weld heat treatment effectiveness
Optimizing welding parameters
Failure analysis of welded components

Key Challenge: Weld samples often contain multiple materials with different hardnesses and microstructures. This requires careful preparation to avoid relief, maintain edge retention, and reveal all zones clearly. The preparation must preserve the integrity of each zone while revealing their distinct microstructural features.

Understanding Weld Zone Regions

Before preparing weld samples, it's important to understand the different regions that will be examined. Each region has distinct characteristics and preparation requirements.

1. Weld Metal (Fusion Zone)

The weld metal is the region where the base metal and filler metal have melted and solidified. Characteristics include:

As-cast microstructure: Columnar grains growing from the fusion boundary toward the weld centerline
Dendritic structure: Often visible in welds, especially in aluminum and stainless steel
Variable composition: May differ from base metal if filler metal is used
Potential defects: Porosity, inclusions, cracks, incomplete fusion

2. Heat-Affected Zone (HAZ)

The HAZ is the region of base metal that was heated but not melted. It experiences microstructural changes due to the thermal cycle. The HAZ typically contains several sub-zones:

Coarse-grained HAZ: Nearest to the weld, where grain growth occurred
Fine-grained HAZ: Where recrystallization occurred
Intercritical HAZ: Where partial transformation occurred (in steels)
Subcritical HAZ: Where only tempering or aging occurred

The HAZ is often the most critical region for weld performance, as it can be the weakest link in the weldment.

3. Fusion Boundary

The fusion boundary is the interface between the weld metal and the HAZ. This region is critical for analysis because:

It marks the transition from melted to unmelted material
It may contain defects such as lack of fusion
It shows the extent of weld penetration
It reveals the quality of the weld fusion

4. Base Metal

The unaffected base metal provides a reference microstructure for comparison. It should show the original material structure without thermal effects from welding.

Preparation Goal: The ideal weld sample preparation reveals all zones clearly with sharp boundaries, no relief between zones, and microstructures that accurately represent each region. This requires careful attention to grinding, polishing, and etching techniques.

Sectioning Weld Samples

Proper sectioning is critical for weld analysis. The section location and orientation determine what can be observed and analyzed.

Section Orientation

Choose section orientation based on what you need to analyze:

Transverse section: Perpendicular to the weld direction - shows the full cross-section including all zones. Most common for general analysis.
Longitudinal section: Parallel to the weld direction - shows weld bead shape, penetration profile, and defects along the weld length.
Oblique section: At an angle - useful for examining specific features or defects.

Section Location

Select section locations that provide the most information:

Weld centerline: Shows the full weld cross-section
Weld toe: Critical area where stress concentrations occur
Weld root: Important for penetration analysis
Defect locations: If defects are suspected, section through them

Sectioning Techniques

Use appropriate sectioning methods to minimize damage:

Abrasive cutoff: Use slow speeds (100-200 RPM) with adequate coolant to prevent overheating
Coolant: Essential to prevent thermal damage to the HAZ microstructure
Multiple cuts: For large samples, make multiple cuts to isolate the region of interest
Preserve features: Leave adequate material around features of interest

Warning: Overheating during sectioning can alter the HAZ microstructure, making it impossible to accurately assess the weld. Always use adequate coolant and appropriate cutting speeds.

Sample Size

Weld samples should be large enough to include:

Complete weld metal cross-section
Full HAZ on both sides (for butt welds)
Adequate base metal for reference
Typically 25-32 mm width is sufficient for most analyses

Sectioning Equipment for Weld Samples

Proper sectioning equipment is essential for preparing weld samples without damaging the HAZ microstructure:

Abrasive Cutoff Machines

Precision cutoff machines with variable speed control and adequate coolant systems are essential for sectioning welds without thermal damage.

View Cutoff Machines →

Cutting Wheels

Appropriate abrasive cutting wheels designed for the material being sectioned help minimize damage and ensure clean cuts.

View Cutting Wheels →

Mounting Considerations

Mounting weld samples provides several advantages and requires specific considerations due to the multiple zones with different properties.

Why Mount Weld Samples

Edge retention: Critical for examining weld boundaries and HAZ
Easier handling: Weld samples are often irregularly shaped
Protection: Prevents damage to delicate weld features
Orientation: Ensures proper orientation for analysis

Mounting Material Selection

Choose mounting materials based on your analysis needs:

Phenolic: Hard, provides excellent edge retention. Preferred for most weld analysis. Good for hardness testing across weld zones.
Epoxy: Softer but still provides good edge retention. Suitable for most applications. Better for preserving delicate features.
Conductive mounting: Required if using automated hardness testers or electrical testing methods.

Mounting Orientation

Mount samples to optimize analysis:

Weld perpendicular to mount surface: Most common orientation - allows examination of all zones in cross-section
Mark weld location: Mark the weld centerline or other features before mounting to maintain orientation
Multiple samples: Can mount multiple weld sections in one mount for comparison

Special Considerations

Porosity preservation: Use vacuum mounting if porosity analysis is needed
Edge protection: Consider using edge protection techniques for delicate weld boundaries
Mount size: Standard 25-32 mm diameter works well for most analyses

Mounting Equipment and Materials

Proper mounting equipment and materials are essential for preserving weld zone boundaries and maintaining edge retention:

Compression Mounting Presses

Compression mounting presses provide consistent pressure and temperature control for mounting weld samples with phenolic or epoxy resins.

View Mounting Presses →

Mounting Materials

Phenolic mounting materials provide excellent edge retention for weld zone analysis, while epoxy materials offer good edge retention with better feature preservation.

View Mounting Materials →

Grinding and Polishing Weld Samples

Weld samples present unique challenges during grinding and polishing due to the different hardnesses and microstructures in each zone. Careful technique is required to avoid relief and maintain zone boundaries.

Grinding Sequence

Use a progressive grinding sequence to remove sectioning damage:

120 grit: Remove sectioning damage (60-90 seconds)
240 grit: Remove previous scratches (60-90 seconds)
400 grit: Further refinement (60-90 seconds)
600 grit: Final grinding step (60-90 seconds)

Grinding Techniques for Welds

Rotate 90°: Rotate sample 90° between each grit to ensure complete scratch removal
Moderate pressure: Use consistent, moderate pressure - avoid excessive pressure that could cause relief
Check zone boundaries: Periodically check that zone boundaries remain visible and sharp
Adequate time: Spend sufficient time at each step to remove all previous scratches
Water lubrication: Use water as lubricant to prevent overheating

Polishing Sequence

Use a progressive polishing sequence:

9 μm diamond: 3-5 minutes on hard cloth (e.g., Texmet)
3 μm diamond: 3-5 minutes on medium-hard cloth
1 μm diamond: 2-3 minutes on soft cloth
0.05 μm colloidal silica: 1-2 minutes on soft cloth (optional, for high-quality finish)

Avoiding Relief

Relief (uneven polishing between zones) is a common problem with weld samples. To minimize relief:

Use appropriate cloths: Harder cloths for harder zones, but avoid too much variation
Moderate pressure: Avoid excessive pressure that can cause differential removal
Shorter polishing times: Don't over-polish - stop when scratches are removed
Check frequently: Examine under microscope to detect relief early
Final polish: Use colloidal silica for final polish to minimize relief

Tip: If relief becomes a problem, return to a coarser polishing step and use lighter pressure and shorter times. Relief is easier to prevent than to fix.

Grinding and Polishing Equipment

Proper grinding and polishing equipment is essential for preparing weld samples without creating relief between zones:

Grinder Polishers

Manual grinder polishers with variable speed control allow precise control over grinding and polishing pressure, essential for avoiding relief in weld samples.

View Grinder Polishers →

Polishing Cloths

Appropriate polishing cloths (hard for initial polishing, soft for final polishing) help minimize relief between weld zones with different hardnesses.

View Polishing Cloths →

Edge Retention

Maintaining sharp zone boundaries is critical for weld analysis:

Hard mounting: Use phenolic or other hard mounting materials
Lighter pressure: Use lighter pressure near boundaries
Shorter times: Avoid over-polishing which can round boundaries
Final check: Verify boundaries are sharp before etching

Etching Techniques for Welds

Etching is critical for revealing weld microstructures. Different zones may require different etchants or etching times. The goal is to reveal all zones clearly with good contrast.

Steel Welds

For carbon and low-alloy steel welds:

2% Nital: Most common etchant for steel welds. Reveals ferrite, pearlite, and martensite structures. Etch for 5-15 seconds, swab or immerse.
4% Picral: Better for revealing pearlite and cementite. Use when nital doesn't provide sufficient contrast.
Vilella's reagent: Good for stainless steel welds. Reveals austenite, ferrite, and sigma phase.
Murakami's reagent: For high-alloy steels and stainless steels. Reveals carbides and intermetallic phases.

Stainless Steel Welds

Stainless steel welds require specialized etchants:

Vilella's reagent: Standard etchant for austenitic stainless steels. Reveals grain boundaries and delta ferrite.
Electrolytic 10% oxalic acid: For detailed microstructural analysis. Use 6V, 30-60 seconds.
Glyceregia: For revealing sigma phase and other intermetallics.

Aluminum Welds

Aluminum welds require different techniques:

Keller's reagent: Standard etchant for aluminum. Reveals grain boundaries and second phases. Etch for 10-20 seconds.
Weck's reagent: For anodizing aluminum to reveal grain structure.
Polarized light: Often useful for aluminum without etching.

Etching Strategy

When etching weld samples:

Start light: Begin with shorter etching times - you can always etch more
Check frequently: Examine under microscope to assess etching progress
Zone-specific: Different zones may etch at different rates - adjust accordingly
Multiple etches: Sometimes multiple etchants are needed to reveal all features
Document: Record etchant and etching time for reproducibility

Etching Tip: If one zone is over-etched while another is under-etched, try using a gentler etchant or shorter time, then selectively re-etch specific zones if needed. Sometimes a compromise is necessary to reveal all zones adequately.

Etching Equipment and Reagents

Proper etching equipment and reagents are essential for revealing weld zone microstructures:

Etching Reagents

Standard etchants like Nital (for steels), Vilella's reagent (for stainless steels), and Keller's reagent (for aluminum) are essential for revealing weld zone microstructures.

View Etchants →

Metallurgical Microscopes

High-quality metallurgical microscopes with reflected light capabilities are essential for examining weld zones, HAZ, and fusion boundaries at appropriate magnifications.

View Microscopes →

Welding Methods and Their Characteristics

Different welding methods produce different microstructures and require specific preparation considerations. Understanding the welding method helps guide preparation and analysis.

TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas) Welding

TIG welding produces high-quality welds with good control. Characteristics:

Narrow HAZ: Concentrated heat input creates a narrow HAZ
Fine microstructure: Typically produces fine-grained weld metal
Good fusion: Usually excellent fusion with base metal
Preparation: Standard preparation techniques work well
Analysis focus: Weld metal quality, HAZ width, fusion boundary

MIG (Metal Inert Gas) / MAG (Metal Active Gas) Welding

MIG/MAG welding is common in production. Characteristics:

Wider HAZ: Higher heat input creates a wider HAZ
Layered structure: Multiple passes create layered microstructure
Potential defects: May have porosity or incomplete fusion between passes
Preparation: May need to examine multiple layers
Analysis focus: Inter-pass regions, HAZ extent, overall weld quality

Friction Stir Welding (FSW)

FSW is a solid-state joining process. Characteristics:

No melting: Material doesn't melt, so no traditional fusion zone
Stir zone: Region where material was plastically deformed and mixed
Thermo-mechanically affected zone (TMAZ): Unique to FSW
Fine grains: Often produces very fine-grained structures
Preparation: Standard techniques, but focus on stir zone and TMAZ
Analysis focus: Stir zone microstructure, TMAZ characteristics, material flow patterns

Electron Beam Welding (EBW)

EBW produces deep, narrow welds. Characteristics:

Very narrow HAZ: Concentrated energy creates extremely narrow HAZ
Deep penetration: Can create very deep welds
Keyhole formation: May have keyhole-related features
Preparation: Standard techniques, but HAZ may be difficult to resolve
Analysis focus: Weld depth, HAZ width, keyhole features

Resistance Welding (Spot, Seam)

Resistance welding creates localized welds. Characteristics:

Small weld nugget: Weld is typically small and localized
Narrow HAZ: Heat is very localized
Preparation: Section through the nugget center
Analysis focus: Nugget size, fusion, HAZ extent

Preparation Note: Regardless of welding method, the fundamental preparation principles remain the same: proper sectioning, mounting, grinding, polishing, and etching. The differences lie in what you're looking for and how the zones appear after preparation.

Defect Detection in Welds

One of the primary purposes of weld metallography is detecting defects that could compromise weld integrity. Proper preparation is essential for accurate defect identification.

Common Weld Defects

Porosity

Appearance: Round or irregular voids in the weld metal
Preparation: Use vacuum mounting to preserve porosity. Avoid over-polishing which can round or close pores.
Analysis: Measure size, distribution, and location

Cracks

Types: Hot cracks, cold cracks, stress corrosion cracks
Preparation: Section through cracks. Use careful polishing to avoid smearing or closing cracks.
Analysis: Identify crack type, location, propagation path, and cause

Incomplete Fusion

Appearance: Lack of fusion between weld passes or between weld and base metal
Preparation: Section to show fusion boundaries clearly. Proper etching reveals lack of fusion.
Analysis: Assess extent and location of incomplete fusion

Inclusions

Types: Slag inclusions, oxide inclusions, tungsten inclusions (in TIG)
Preparation: Standard preparation, but avoid over-polishing which can pull out inclusions
Analysis: Identify type, size, and distribution

Undercut

Appearance: Groove at weld toe where base metal was melted away
Preparation: Section through weld toe. Maintain edge retention to show undercut clearly.
Analysis: Measure depth and assess severity

Preparation for Defect Analysis

Section location: Section through suspected defects
Preserve defects: Use techniques that preserve defect morphology
Avoid artifacts: Distinguish real defects from preparation artifacts
Multiple sections: Sometimes multiple sections are needed to fully characterize defects
Documentation: Document defect location, size, and characteristics

Important: Be careful to distinguish real defects from preparation artifacts. Pullouts, smearing, and contamination can look like defects. Experience and careful preparation help avoid misidentification.

Microstructure Analysis of Weld Zones

Each weld zone has characteristic microstructures that provide information about weld quality, properties, and potential issues. Understanding what to look for in each zone guides effective analysis.

Weld Metal Microstructure

The weld metal microstructure depends on composition, cooling rate, and welding parameters:

Columnar grains: Growing from fusion boundary toward centerline
Dendritic structure: Visible in many welds, especially aluminum and stainless steel
Second phases: Precipitates, inclusions, or intermetallics
Grain size: Can vary across the weld
Defects: Porosity, cracks, inclusions

HAZ Microstructure

The HAZ microstructure reveals the thermal history:

Grain growth: Coarse grains in the high-temperature region
Phase transformations: In steels, may show martensite, bainite, or other transformation products
Precipitation: May show over-aging or dissolution of precipitates
Recrystallization: Fine grains in recrystallized regions
Softening: In age-hardened alloys, may show softening

Fusion Boundary

The fusion boundary should show:

Sharp transition: Clear boundary between weld and base metal
Good fusion: No gaps or lack of fusion
Grain growth: Grains growing from base metal into weld
No defects: No cracks or other defects at the boundary

Analysis Magnifications

Use appropriate magnifications for different analyses:

Low (50-100x): Overall weld structure, zone identification, defect location
Medium (200-500x): Detailed microstructure, grain structure, phase identification
High (500-1000x): Fine details, precipitates, small defects

Weld Microstructure Examples

Understanding typical weld microstructures helps in analysis and interpretation. When examining weld samples, look for:

Stainless Steel Welds

• Distinct weld metal with columnar grains
• HAZ showing grain growth and phase changes
• Delta ferrite in austenitic welds
• Fusion boundary clearly visible

Etched with Vilella's reagent or electrolytic oxalic acid

Carbon Steel Welds

• Weld metal with as-cast microstructure
• HAZ showing grain growth and transformation
• Possible martensite or bainite in HAZ
• Base metal with original structure

Etched with 2% Nital or 4% Picral

Aluminum Welds

• Dendritic structure in weld metal
• Recrystallized grains in HAZ
• Precipitate distribution changes
• Possible softening in HAZ

Etched with Keller's reagent or anodized

Friction Stir Welds

• Stir zone with fine recrystallized grains
• TMAZ showing deformation structure
• Material flow patterns
• No traditional fusion zone

Material-specific etchants required

Note: Actual microstructures will vary based on welding method, material composition, process parameters, and heat treatment. Always compare observed microstructures with expected structures for the specific material and welding process. Document all observations with photographs at appropriate magnifications.

Documentation

Document your analysis with:

Photographs: At appropriate magnifications showing all zones
Measurements: Zone widths, grain sizes, defect sizes
Descriptions: Microstructural features observed
Comparisons: Compare with specifications or standards

Best Practices for Weld Analysis

Following best practices ensures reliable, reproducible weld analysis results.

Preparation Best Practices

Plan ahead: Determine what you need to analyze before sectioning
Proper sectioning: Use appropriate speeds and coolant to prevent damage
Consistent technique: Follow standardized procedures for reproducibility
Check progress: Examine samples at each preparation step
Avoid relief: Use appropriate techniques to minimize relief
Proper etching: Use correct etchants and times for the material

Analysis Best Practices

Systematic examination: Examine all zones systematically
Multiple magnifications: Use different magnifications for different purposes
Document everything: Record all observations and measurements
Compare zones: Compare weld zones with base metal
Reference standards: Use applicable standards for evaluation
Expert consultation: Consult experts when needed

Quality Control

Standard procedures: Follow documented procedures consistently
Calibration: Ensure equipment is properly calibrated
Reference samples: Use reference samples to verify procedures
Training: Ensure operators are properly trained
Review: Have results reviewed by qualified personnel

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Overheating during sectioning: Can alter HAZ microstructure
Excessive relief: Makes zone boundaries unclear
Over-etching: Can obscure microstructural details
Poor edge retention: Makes boundary analysis difficult
Inadequate documentation: Makes results difficult to reproduce or verify
Misidentifying artifacts: Confusing preparation artifacts with real features

Remember: Good weld analysis requires patience and attention to detail. Take time at each step to ensure proper preparation. The quality of your analysis depends directly on the quality of your preparation.